The Solution to Engine Vibration
Although vibration can come from tires, wheels, brake discs
etc., the majority of vibration in a V-twin comes from the engine. This
occurs in two areas:
Torque Vibration and Vibration from the rotating mass unbalance.
Torque vibration is caused by the engine firing on the power stroke.
The benefits of having your flywheel assembly dynamically balanced are:
1) smoother operation (less vibration)
2) longer bearing life
3) more usable horsepower
4) higher rpm (usually more important in racing applications)
The amount of vibration varies with the engine load; the greater the load,
the more severe the power impulse, the greater the vibration. As the
cylinder fires, the piston is forced down and at the same time the cylinder
head is forced up. (Newton's law: for every action there is an equal and
opposite reaction.) Since the cylinder is fastened to the crankcase, and the
crankcase is fastened to the motorcycle frame, the result is vibration. For
example:6,000 rpm is 100 power cycles per second = torque vibration.
The second source of vibration is the rotating mass of the flywheels.
The rotating mass is the total weight of the rods, pistons, rings, and
complete flywheel assembly.
A rotating unit that is in perfect balance rotates concentrically around the
center line of the axis of rotation. A rotating unit that is not in perfect
balance tends to rotate in an elliptical (egg shaped) manner, around the
center line of the axis axis rotation, with the elongated portion of the
ellipse at the point of unbalance.The more unbalanced, the more exaggerated
the ellipse. Of course, the elliptical movement caused by the unbalance is
restrained by the ball bearings. It follows that the greater the elliptical
motion of the flywheels, the greater the wear on the ball bearings. For
example, as the speed of the engine doubles, the amount of force, per
revolution, created unbalance tends to increase by an approximate factor of
four.
Example: 1 ounce inch of unbalance at 2,000 rpm creates approximately 7
pounds of force per rpm. One ounce inch of unbalance at 4,000 rpm creates
approximately 23 pounds of force per rpm.
One ounce inch of unbalance at 8,000 rpm creates approximately 120 pounds of
force per rpm. Unbalance is typically expressed in ounce inches (oz. in.).
This means 1 ounce (28.35 grams) of unbalance at 1-inch radius.If it takes "X"
amount of horsepower to generate "X" amount of rpm for an engine with
unbalance; it follows that it will take less horsepower to generate the same
amount of rpm with a balanced engine, because your are not losing horsepower
overcoming the effects of the unbalance. Reasons three and four for having
the flywheel custom balanced-more horsepower and higher rpm.
So what does this really mean? Typically, the closer your flywheel assembly
is to perfect balance, the less vibration you have. By balancing correctly
and accurately, the vibration production from vibrating rotating mass can,
in most cases, be greatly reduced.
I really don't know what the balancing tolerance (to what accuracy) the
stock Harley-Davidson flywheel assembly is balanced at the factory. Rumor
has it that they balance by an average weight of components, then they apply
that formula to all engines. Some shops try to balance to .5 ounces inches.
However our shop balances Harley flywheel assemblies to less than .5 ounces
inches. To put it another way ".5" ounce inches of balancing tolerance is
3.336 grams placed on the outside diameter of the flywheels note: a $1 bill
= 1 gram.
It is especially important to have the flywheel assembly custom balanced if
you have cut down or lightened the flywheels, crankpin, changed pistons, put
in different rods, or stroked or destroked the crank. For example: Let's say
that the engine is in good balance but you want to go with a bigger
piston.The new pistons, rings, etc. weigh 100 grams more, each, than the
pistons you took out This would mean that the would be out of balance by 62
grams (8.2 oz. in) at the outside diameter of the flywheel assembly.
Why custom balance your modified Harley Davidson flywheel assembly? The
obvious advantage is that the flywheels are balanced for the exact
components you are using in your engine. You'll also have the smoothest
running scoot on the block.