Classic commutator DC motor
Many of the limitations of the classic commutator DC motor are due to the
need for brushes to press against the commutator. This creates friction. At
higher speeds, brushes have increasing difficulty in maintaining contact.
Brushes may bounce off the irregularities in the commutator surface,
creating sparks. This limits the maximum speed of the machine. The current
density per unit area of the brushes limits the output of the motor. The
imperfect electric contact also causes electrical noise. Brushes eventually
wear out and require replacement, and the commutator itself is subject to
wear and maintenance. The commutator assembly on a large machine is a costly
element, requiring precision assembly of many parts.
are eliminated in the brushless design. In this motor, the mechanical "rotating
switch" or commutator/brushgear assembly is replaced by an external
electronic switch synchronised to the rotor's position. Brushless motors are
typically 85-90% efficient, whereas DC motors with brushgear are typically
75-80% efficient.
Midway between ordinary DC motors and stepper motors lies the realm of the
brushless DC motor. Built in a fashion very similar to stepper motors, these
often use a permanent magnet external rotor, three phases of driving coils,
one or more Hall effect sensors to sense the position of the rotor, and the
associated drive electronics. The coils are activated, one phase after the
other, by the drive electronics as cued by the signals from the Hall effect
sensors. In effect, they act as three-phase synchronous motors containing
their own variable-frequency drive electronics. A specialized class of
brushless DC motor controllers utilize EMF feedback through the main phase
connections instead of Hall effect sensors to determine position and
velocity. These motors are used extensively in electric radio-controlled
vehicles. When configured with the magnets on the outside, these are
referred to by modelists as outrunner motors.
Brushless DC motors are commonly used where precise speed control is
necessary, as in computer disk drives or in video cassette recorders, the
spindles within CD, CD-ROM (etc.) drives, and mechanisms within office
products such as fans, laser printers and photocopiers. They have several
advantages over conventional motors:
Compared to AC fans using shaded-pole motors, they are very efficient,
running much cooler than the equivalent AC motors. This cool operation leads
to much-improved life of the fan's bearings.
Without a commutator to wear out, the life of a DC brushless motor can be
significantly longer compared to a DC motor using brushes and a commutator.
Commutation also tends to cause a great deal of electrical and RF noise;
without a commutator or brushes, a brushless motor may be used in
electrically sensitive devices like audio equipment or computers.
The same Hall effect sensors that provide the commutation can also provide a
convenient tachometer signal for closed-loop control (servo-controlled)
applications. In fans, the tachometer signal can be used to derive a "fan OK"
signal.
The motor can be easily synchronized to an internal or external clock,
leading to precise speed control.
Brushless motors have no chance of sparking, unlike brushed motors, making
them better suited to environments with volatile chemicals and fuels.
Brushless motors are usually used in small equipment such as computers and
are generally used to get rid of unwanted heat.
They are also very quiet motors which is an advantage if being used in
equipment that is affected by vibrations.
Modern DC brushless motors range in power from a fraction of a watt to many
kilowatts. Larger brushless motors up to about 100 kW rating are used in
electric vehicles. They also find significant use in high-performance
electric model aircraft.